In forming opinions on policy, it’s good to balance research and lived experience.
Research is an invaluable tool in helping us test our beliefs, but the most rigorous research is limited to what can be measured, and not everything can be measured.
When it comes to public school policy, attending school board meetings has been a major part of my lived experience.
Over the past decade, I’ve attended two different types of school board meetings: elected school board meetings and non-profit charter school board meetings.
The elected school board meetings I’ve attended range from dysfunctional (school board members screaming at each other) to misguided (school board members discussing random topics that have little to do with governing public schools) to sometimes useful (reasoned debate on systems level policy).
Unfortunately, I’ve attended many more dysfunctional and misguided elected school board meetings than I’ve attended useful elected school board meetings.
The non-profit charter school board meetings tend to be much more productive. More often than not, the board members are focused and knowledgeable. This is especially true of larger non-profit charter networks, where the board has been around for over a decade and governed through organization scaling.
Yes, I’ve attended a few dysfunctional charter school board meetings, but they are not the norm.
This lived experience in attending board meetings has shaped my policy views. Based on a decade of attending board meetings, I believe that non-profit boards will be better at governing schools than elected boards will be.
I do believe we need democratic oversight over our public schools. Elections allow us to debate values, and these values should shape how we oversee our public schools.This oversight can come in a variety of forms, from elected boards to mayoral control. The New Orleans elected school board, for example, oversees a nearly 100% non-profit charter schools system.
But while we need elections to debate values, we don’t need elections to govern individual or networks of schools.
My lived experience leads me to believe that this duty is best held by non-profit boards.